EDUC 605 - Murillo
Consensus Theory -Positivism Conflict Theory
- Functionalism (Durkheim) - Functional Structuralism (Talcott-Parsons) |
- Historical Materialism (Marx) - Power / Bureaucracy (Weber) |
Social equilibrium is the inherent and natural state of the system. (Dominant framework of the 20th century.) |
Conflict is the inherent and natural state of the system. |
Organic analogy arguing that society possesses basic functions analogous to biological living organisms. The needs of the organism are called functions, and the parts of the organism
are called structures. |
Contradiction of capitalism, economic determinism, and patterns of property ownership between labor and capital. |
Society is social system with various needs of its own, that must be met. |
Society is the setting within various struggles take place. |
Social inequality is a function of hard work, innate talent, and selection by others. |
Social inequality arises through coercive institutions (force, fraud, & inheritance). |
Social inequality comes from human nature. |
Social inequality is the chief source of conflict. |
“State” and laws as organs of total society, acting basically to promote the common good. |
“State” and laws as instruments of oppression employed by the ruling classes for their own benefit. |
Social class as aggregations of people with certain common characteristics. |
Social class as social groups with distinctive interests, which inevitably brings them to conflict. |
What function does it serve? |
For whom is it functional? |
Durkheim: each part has a function, ensuring survival of the whole. Inherent functions of society are reproduction, cultural transmission, and the distribution of authority. The function of schools is to pass on certain values. |
Marx: unequal distribution of wealth and goods in society is the unequivocal source of conflict. The base or foundation of economics determines social institutions and practices (such as schools). |
Talcott-Parsons: without an efficient mechanism of socialization, social order and harmony is impossible. Common culture and values are pre-conditions for social stability. Achievement and Equality of Opportunity (mostly through schooling) are fundamental to create societal consensus. |
Weber: Conflicts related to class are necessarily the only ones central as a whole. The “state” is the mediator of conflict, rather than the expression of the interests of the dominant class. Schools are formal and multi-leveled bureaucracies, unlike industrial corporations and other prototypical social organizations. Stratification stems from Economic power, Prestige power, and Political power. |